Get Messy White Gays tickets on New York Theatre Guide to see a hilarious new satire about drinks, dishing, and drama. Written by Drew Droege, who was last seen in Titanique off Broadway, Messy White Gays plays at The Duke on 42nd Street this fall with a stacked cast of gay performers: joining Droege are Tony Award nominee James Cusati-Moyer (Slave Play), Aaron Jackson (Dicks: The Musical), Zane Phillips (Fire Island), and Pete Zias (The Teddy Teddy Show).
Experience Messy White Gays off Broadway, and get ready for a dish that is best served... after brunch. It's Sunday morning in Hell’s Kitchen. Brecken and Caden have just murdered their throuple-mate and stuffed him into a Jonathan Adler credenza. Unfortunately, they’ve also invited friends over for brunch. Feel bad for them! The limes are running low! They're messy white gays!
After appearing in Search Party, Heathers, and Bob's Burgers, Droege's new comedy shines a harsh overhead light on the pores of White Gaydom, revealing what happens when throuples crumble, neighbors bicker, and rich and pretty clash with hot and dumb. The play is also in good hands: director Mike Donahue staged the LA premiere of The Inheritance at the Geffen and also Little Shop of Horrors with MJ Rodriguez, George Salazar and Amber Riley. He knows how to work with a starry cast, and this one will deliver as well: all five actors have extensive experience in comedy, live theatre, and singularly gay stories.
Skewering a specific part of New York culture, Messy White Gays holds no punches. If you are a (messy) white gay, the show will be a mirror, and if you aren't, come have a laugh at this goofy group's shenanigans! It is sure to be a riot. Tickets to Messy White Gays in New York are available now.
1hr 30min.
Ages 16+.
October 6th, 2025
January 11th, 2026
By: Drew Droege
Director: Mike Donahue
Cast list: Drew Droege (as Karl), James Cusati-Moyer (as Brecken), Aaron Jackson (as Caden), Zane Phillips (as Addison), Pete Zias (as Thacker)
Sets: Alexander Dodge
Costumes: James + AC
Lighting: Jen Schriever
Sound: Sinan Refik Zadar
Other info: Props by Brendan McCann, puppetry by Sam Hill, special effects by Jeremy Chernick
Wheelchair access
Get tickets to Messy White Gays off Broadway, or sign up to receive our latest news and show alerts.
Day of week | Evening |
---|---|
Monday | 7:30 PM |
Tuesday | 7:30 PM |
Wednesday | 7:30 PM |
Thursday | 7:30 PM |
Friday | 7:30 PM |
Saturday | 5:00 PM, 9:00 PM |
Sunday | - |
Messy White Gays is a campy new comedy about a gay brunch gone wrong in all the best ways.
The running time of Messy White Gays is 1hr 30min.
Messy White Gays is playing at Duke on 42nd Street. The theatre is located at 229 West 42nd Street (between 7th and 8th Avenue), New York , 10036.
Tickets for Messy White Gays start at $59.
The recommended age for Messy White Gays is Ages 16+..
Book tickets for Messy White Gays on New York Theatre Guide.
You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy