NYTG Logo
Two men sit together on a stage set, with one man embracing the other from behind, both looking upward in a dimly lit, purple-toned scene.

Photo credit: Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy in The Fantasticks on Broadway. (Photo by Joan Marcus)

'The Fantasticks' Broadway review — long-running musical makes a heartstopping Broadway debut

Read our review of The Fantasticks, a reimagined production of Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt's musical whose two Off-Broadway runs played for a combined 53 years.

Summary

  • The Fantasticks tells the story of two boys whose moms fake a feud so their sons will fall in love
  • The musical is making its Broadway debut after a record-setting 53 total years off Broadway
  • The current production features a reimagined same-sex love story by original Fantasticks co-creator Tom Jones
  • The show is recommended for fans of TV shows like Heated Rivalry and Heartstopper, and appreciators of The Fantasticks's storied history
Joe Dziemianowicz
Joe Dziemianowicz

Deep into The Fantasticks, two young men mutually realize the immensity of what they mean to each other. “All my wildest dreams multiplied by two,” they gloriously harmonize, side by side. The moment is just what you hope for in a musical — a heartstopper.

The rest of The Fantasticks doesn't rise quite so high, but there’s more to like in this beautifully sung version of book writer/lyricist Tom Jones and composer Harvey Schmidt’s 66-year-old musical making its Broadway debut. The show arrives at the Hayes Theater with bragging rights as the world’s longest-running musical and hummable hits like “Try to Remember,” “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” and “They Were You.” The show also arrives with its imperfections.

Director/choreographer Christopher Gattelli's production lands with a gender-bending revision crafted by Jones. Boy-meets-girl is now boy-meets-boy, and we meet the pair’s mothers, not their fathers. It’s The Fantasticks in the time of Heartstopper and Heated Rivalry, TV series that came to mind thanks to the gay love stories and, to some degree, physical echoes in the blond-brunette pairs.

The same-sex concept wasn’t in the cards in 1960. But now, as ever, the players share a fable about innocence and experience. We follow 20-year-old bookish Matt (Maxim Chlumecky, just plain wonderful), starry-eyed 18-year-old Lewis (Nathan Levy), and their respective moms, Mildred (Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, a head-to-toe comic ace) and Bessie Mae (Ruthie Ann Miles). They’re introduced by the narrator El Gallo (Zane Phillips, appealing but static), who gets everyone’s hearts purring.

A barrier wall devised by the mothers to, via reverse psychology, unite their kids is realized by a confetti-tossing, nonspeaking actor (Ahmad Simmons) with a top hat. Kevin Del Aguila and David Patrick Kelly pop in and out as scenery-chewing actors.

Bare-bones simplicity has always been key to The Fantasticks's storytelling and staging as the lovers’ relationship is tested, bruised, and burnished by hard knocks. Save for some fake botanicals and a banana-yellow peekaboo moon, Gattelli wisely heeds the less-is-more legacy. Broadway provides a bigger playing space, but that doesn’t get in the way.

Reimagining the show, however, doesn’t erase nagging issues that were there during my first encounter in 2006. The early stretch is too precious for its own good, and a staged kidnapping of “young innocent boys” so Matt can prove his love is cringe. And in this redo, the iconic “I want” song “Much More” isn’t a perfect fit for Lewis even with minor lyric tweaks. Do gay boys yearn for the same thing as straight girls? Love may be love may be love. But desire? It’s not a one-sigh-fits-all affair, so the section feels forced.

In the end, what stands out most is that while the moms have problems with each other's gardening approaches, their gay sons are a total non-issue. Six decades since the show burst on the scene, that feels like progress worth singing about. Better, it’s fantastic.

7 fantasticks-1200x600-NYTG

The Fantasticks summary

Inspired by Edmond Rostand’s 1894 work Les Romanesques, the musical The Fantasticks involves parents who fake a feud so their kids will rebel, meet, and fall for each other. Love doesn’t run smoothly.

The musical debuted Off-Broadway in 1960, where it ran for 42 years. A 2006 revival ran until 2017, shortly before Schmidt’s death. Jones revised the show as gay love story before his death in 2023, and that version is seen in The Fantasticks's current Broadway debut.

What to expect at The Fantasticks

The Fantasticks has notched its place in the theatre history books, and it begins with a sweet kiss to the past. On stage at the Hayes Theater, there’s a harp and a piano, a nod to the minimal instrumentation in the show made to be intentionally small for the 1960 premiere. Now, there’s an eight-piece orchestra. There’s also a prop box labeled "Sullivan Street Theater" — the venue where the show began.

In the show, a wall is a key character. On Broadway, we see another exposed brick wall that’s designed by Jason Sherwood. At various points, windows and doors open to reveal the sky, sun, moon, and people in the distance. Jen Schriever’s dynamic lighting turns the whitewashed wall various shades to underscore the action. Linda Cho’s delightful costumes — with stripes and checks for the boys and florals for the moms — strike just the right notes of character definition and bright fun.

The Fantasticks runs 2 hours and 15 minutes, including an intermission.

3 fantasticks-1200x600-NYTG

What audiences are saying about The Fantasticks

As of writing, The Fantasticks has an 82% approval rating on the review aggregator Show-Score, reflecting mixed reactions from early theatregoers.

  • “A ‘new’ version of the classic play with great performances, beautiful music, and inventive staging.” - Show-Score user Michael 6151
  • “Too surface level for me – needed more depth.” - Show-Score user Jordan 4906
  • “Delightful reimaging, bordering on the magical. Lovely.” - Show-Score user Arthur 3333.
  • "I enjoyed it AND it was disappointing. The music offered great memories of theater songs past. The mothers were the highlight. [...] The boy's struggles were never felt and looked pantomined comic-strip - and therefore their 'growth' did not register emotionally." - Show-Score user Mitch
  • “A charming and melodic musical, the likes of which we rarely see on Broadway anymore.” - Show-Score user C-Pax

Read more audience reviews of The Fantasticks on Show-Score.

Who should see The Fantasticks

  • Theatregoers who saw the show’s original Off-Broadway run or the 2006 revival will want to see the reimagined version.
  • Fans of gay love stories like TV's Heartstopper and (admittedly sexier) Heated Rivalry will appreciate this musical’s spot in the genre.
  • Musical theatre devotees will want to see the show that occupies such a strong place in stage history.

Learn more about The Fantasticks on Broadway

The Fantasticks is a little show with deceptively big things to say about life, love, and forgiveness. Its return to New York is a welcome one.

Photo credit: The Fantasticks on Broadway. (Photos by Joan Marcus)

Frequently asked questions

What's the age recommendation for The Fantasticks?

The recommended age for The Fantasticks is Ages 5+. Children under 5 will not be admitted..

Where is The Fantasticks playing?

The Fantasticks is playing at Hayes Theater. The theatre is located at 240 West 44th Street, New York, 10036.

How long is The Fantasticks?

The running time of The Fantasticks is 2hr 15min. Incl 1 intermission.

How do you book tickets for The Fantasticks?

Book tickets for The Fantasticks on New York Theatre Guide.

How much do tickets cost for The Fantasticks?

Tickets for The Fantasticks start at $65.

What is The Fantasticks about?

The Fantasticks is a musical comedy about two mothers who start a fake feud so that their two sons will fall in love.

What are the songs in The Fantasticks?

The musical features many beloved show tunes like "Try to Remember" and "Soon It's Gonna Rain."

Who directs The Fantasticks?

Tony winner Christopher Gattelli directs and choreographs this fresh production.

Who wrote The Fantasticks?

With music by Harvey Schmidt and lyrics and a revised book by Tom Jones, this musical won the Tony Honors for Excellence in Theatre in 1991.

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy